Corporate Credit Analyst
×
x
David Kratz
Corporate Credit Analyst
Investment
industry experience since 2004
David joined Weitz Investment Management in 2004. He has held
multiple roles with the firm, including client services representative,
equity intern, internal wholesaler and product specialist. In 2017, he joined the fixed
income team as a research associate. David has a bachelor's in
finance, a master's in security analysis and portfolio management, and an MBA
from Creighton University.
Vista Global Holding Limited (Vista) is
a private aviation platform comprised of two established brands, VistaJet and
XO. While headquartered in Dubai, 57% of flight revenue is generated in the
U.S. and 23% is generated in Europe. The company has six operations hubs and
over 20 offices worldwide.
VistaJet, founded in 2004, is a
value-driven flying solution for corporate leaders and private individuals. VistaJet
passengers have flown to over 1,900 airports in 187 countries, covering 96% of
the world. VistaJet's subscription model offers guaranteed availability with as
little as 24 hours' notice, globally, on a consistent branded fleet. The VistaJet
Members' fleet of over 360 aircraft is capable of continental trips on
super-midsize and large-cabin aircraft, to long-range trips connecting
continents, and even non-stop 17-hour flights with Vista's stable of 18 Bombardier
Global 7500s. Through a three-year contract, VistaJet offers three types of
memberships which are largely dependent on the number of hours an individual or
entity desires to fly at a transparent, fixed hourly rate. Variability in fuel prices is a non-issue for
Vista as costs are passed through to its members.
XO, founded in 2018 as XOJET, offers
whole aircraft private charter flights as well as seats on shared charters,
seamlessly and instantly bookable through the XO mobile app. Members and
clients can request flights on over 2,400 aircraft worldwide, including the 360+
aircraft in the Vista Members' fleet and the safety-vetted XO alliance fleet of
2,100+ private aircraft covering all cabin classes.
Vista has a diversified client base
across industry and geography. The top 20 clients contribute to less than 6% of
the group's revenues.
Prepared for
Future Growth
We initiated our coverage of Vista in January
2020. Since then, Vista has transformed from a highly leveraged travel
alternative trying to keep up with demand, to a company with improved fundamentals,
scaled for future growth with no current need for further fleet investment.
Since our initiation, Vista's revenues
have doubled, secured debt as a percentage of total debt has decreased from 67%
to a pro forma 49%, and net leverage has decreased from 8.2x to 4.5x. The member
fleet has expanded from 115 to more than 360 aircraft. Participants in
VistaJet's Program membership (the company's most comprehensive personal
membership with a fixed hourly rate and guaranteed aircraft availability) have increased
from 500 to 970. Pro forma liquidity is healthy at $280 million, including a
fully available revolving credit facility of $145 million.
Vista spent 2022 preparing for future
growth. The COVID-19 pandemic led to rapid growth and healthy demand, which encouraged
significant expansion of Vista's fleet. Vista added 115 new dedicated aircraft in
2022 through planned aircraft deliveries and acquisitions. Production
shortfalls created challenges for Vista and other industry participants to
acquire new aircraft, forcing Vista to turn to acquisition for fleet growth. Vista
acquired Air Hamburg — the largest private jet operator in Europe by number of
flights, and Jet Edge — a leading U.S. provider of large-cabin and
super-midsize charter and aircraft management services. Combined, they considerably
expanded Vista's scale, offering flexibility and efficiency to their customers.
Vista added 240 program members in 2022 and appears on pace for an additional
240 program members in 2023.
Today,
Vista's fleet is underutilized, as the company has added fleet faster than
customers. Management desires
70% of revenues to be generated by their VistaJet members, but today that
number is closer to 50%. In the meantime, XO members
can access the VistaJet Members' fleet which is higher margin for Vista than using
the XO alliance fleet. In turn, this access to the VistaJet Members' fleet may
persuade those using the ad hoc XO mobile app to sign-up for a VistaJet
membership. Future growth is expected to be largely driven by transitioning
those that own or are contemplating buying an aircraft to instead purchase a VistaJet
membership. VistaJet, like most private aviation companies, does not publish a
specific price list. Its online comparison tool entices potential members by
sharing how much they could save using the Program membership compared to
owning a jet. For example, if you were to own a Bombardier
6000 and fly around 50 hours per year, you could expect to save over $150,000
per flight hour with a VistaJet membership based on depreciation and running
costs. Even at today's pace of VistaJet member adoption, Vista has years to
reach full capacity. Historical retention of VistaJet members has been
approximately 90%.
Vista
says deleveraging is a top priority. For 2023, management
anticipates $250 million of debt repayment through natural amortization as well
as continued EBITDA (earnings
before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) growth. In addition,
the company expects to generate $150 million per year in free cash flow which
could be used for additional debt paydown as well. While management does not
have a stated leverage target, they have mentioned that a net debt of 3x feels
healthy. If we assume $250 million of naturally occurring amortization and $150
million of free cash flow towards debt, it is plausible that net debt could be
reduced to 4.0x by the end of 2023; a far cry from the 8.2x in 2020.
Industry
While the pandemic hurt many
industries, it actually helped private aviation. Demand increased due to a shift
in corporations and high-net-worth individuals' desire to travel safely. New
flyers entered the market after the pandemic practically shut down commercial
airliners in 2020. These newcomers are generally affluent passengers who would
traditionally travel in first-class seats but never thought they needed to fly
privately. After experiencing the perks of private aviation — the lack of
disruption of canceled flights, crowded airports, and security checkpoints — many
will likely be private aviation users for the long haul.
Forbes predicts private jet market growth
will continue, and the overall private aviation market will emerge from the
pandemic 5% to 10% larger than before. According to Latitude 33 Aviation, prior
to the pandemic, only 10% of those who could afford to fly privately did so.
Now, research estimates that 79% of people who can afford a private jet are
inclined to fly privately. In addition, 53% of new private flyers say they plan
to fly privately on a regular basis post-pandemic.
Industry pundits say those that own
their own aircraft and fly fewer than 400 hours per year are underutilizing
their aircraft. Per the private jet company NetJets, “most evaluations on the cost
of a private jet do not account for depreciation, and the variable costs for
maintaining and operating a private jet are considerable.” This sets the stage for
why we believe demand at private aviation platforms such as Vista or the fractional
ownership model at NetJets is likely to continue to prosper.
A VistaJet contract and NetJets'
fractional aircraft ownership program are quite different. VistaJet is a five-page
contract that basically states that Vista has an obligation to transport, and
the client has an obligation to pay. Prices range from around $12,000 to
$20,000 per hour depending on membership level and aircraft. NetJets has a
roughly 150-to-200-page contract including a share-purchase agreement,
operating agreement, and surcharge agreement. Fractional ownership requires
significant investment and ongoing expenses, including monthly management fees
and flight costs.
Currently, Vista has an approximately 2%
market share in an estimated $67 billion fragmented market, along with significant
whitespace for organic growth. NetJets is the market leader with approximately 10%
market share.
Our History with
Vista
At our initiation of coverage back in
January 2020, Vista was rated: Caa1 by Moody's and B+ by Fitch. As management executed
its playbook, positive rating migration followed. Today, Vista is rated B3 by
Moody's and BB- by Fitch. As of June 30, 2023, we own Vista
corporate bonds maturing in 2027 and 2030 in the Core Plus Income Fund. Our allocation
to Vista in Fund is approximately 0.5% of assets and approximately 10% of the
Fund's total high-yield allocation. The Vista securities that mature in 2027 trade
at approximately 400 bps (4%) wide to B-rated consumer discretionary names, and,
if held to maturity, will generate a yield of 11.3%. We believe we are
being compensated more than appropriately for the risk.
Looking Ahead
We believe Vista's platform has been
scaled to support the next 3-to-5 years of growth. Growth is expected to
continue through Vista's contractual, asset-lite offering which continues to
demonstrate strong momentum. We believe incremental EBITDA growth can be
achieved through fleetwide utilization of program sales and optimizing
operations. Currently, management has announced no further M&A targets, no
capital expenditure commitments, and no financing needs to bolster liquidity.
In our view, the contractual nature of
the program sales combined with Vista's historical retention rate of
approximately 90%, ample whitespace for organic growth, lack of additional
M&A/fleet needs, low capital commitments, annual free cash flow generation,
and reasonable liquidity indicate that strong fundamentals are here to stay through
the maturity of our allocation.
Continued deleveraging is expected via
EBITDA growth, the natural amortization of fleet debt (which increases free
cash flow), possible leverage-neutral unsecured issuances to unencumber the
balance sheet and debt reduction via free cash flow. It is conceivable that
further ratings upgrades are possible and spread compression warranted.
/sitefiles/live/documents/AnalystCorner/Analyst_Corner_Vista.pdf
The opinions expressed are those of
Weitz Investment Management and are not meant as investment advice or to
predict or project the future performance of any investment product. The
opinions are current through 08/01/2023, they are subject to change at any time
based on market and other current conditions, and no forecasts can be
guaranteed. This commentary is being provided as a general source of
information and is not intended as a recommendation to purchase, sell, or hold
any specific security or to engage in any investment strategy. Investment
decisions should always be made based on an investor's specific objectives,
financial needs, risk tolerance and time horizon.
Credit ratings are assigned to
underlying securities utilizing ratings from a Nationally Recognized
Statistical Rating Organization (NRSRO) such as Moody's and Fitch, or other
rating agencies and applying the following hierarchy: security is determined to
be Investment Grade if it has been rated at least BBB- by one credit rating
agency; once determined to be Investment Grade (BBB- and above) or
Non-Investment Grade (BB+ and below) where multiple ratings are available, the
lowest rating is assigned. Mortgage-related securities issued and guaranteed by
government-sponsored agencies such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are generally
not rated by rating agencies. Securities that are not rated do not necessarily
indicate low quality. Ratings are shown in the Fitch scale (e.g., AAA). Ratings
and portfolio credit quality may change over time. The Fund itself has not been
rated by a credit rating agency.