Value Fund : Proxy Voting

Click on company name to expand

A arrow B arrow C arrow D arrow E arrow H arrow L arrow M arrow O arrow P arrow R arrow T arrow U arrow W arrow

  accenture plc
Ticker: ACN CUSIP: G1151C101
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 2/3/2016        

1. re-appointment of director: jaime ardila, dina dublon, charles h. giancarlo, william l. kimsey, marjorie magner, blythe j. mcgarvie, pierre nanterme, gilles c. pelisson, paula a. price, arun sarin, wulf von schimmelmann, frank k. tang m for yes for
2. to approve, in a non-binding vote, the compensation of our named executive officers. m for yes for
3. to approve an amendment to the amended and restated accenture plc 2010 share incentive plan to increase the number of shares available for issuance, establish limits on annual compensation granted to our non-employee directors and make other amendments. m for yes for
4. to approve an amendment to the accenture plc 2010 employee share purchase plan to increase the number of shares available for issuance and make other amendments. m for yes for
5. to ratify, in a non-binding vote, the appointment of kpmg llp (kpmg) as the independent auditors of accenture and to authorize, in a binding vote, the audit committee of the board of directors to determine kpmg's remuneration. m for yes for
6. to amend the company's articles of association to implement "proxy access." m for yes for
7a. to amend the company's articles of association to enhance the advance notice provisions and make certain administrative amendments. m for yes for
7b. to amend the company's memorandum of association to make certain administrative amendments. m for yes for
8a. to amend the company's articles of association to provide for plurality voting in the event of a contested election. m for yes for
8b. to amend the company's articles of association to grant the board sole authority to determine its size. m for yes for
9. to grant the board of directors the authority to issue shares under irish law. m for yes for
10. to grant the board of directors the authority to opt-out of statutory pre-emption rights under irish law. m for yes for
11. to authorize accenture and its subsidiaries to make open-market purchases of accenture class a ordinary shares under irish law. m for yes for
12. to determine the price range at which accenture can re-allot shares that it acquires as treasury shares under irish law. m for yes for

  allergan plc
Ticker: AGN CUSIP: G0177J108
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/5/2016        

1. director: nesli basgoz, m.d., paul m. bisaro, james h. bloem, christopher w. bodine, christopher j. coughlin, michael r. gallagher, catherine m. klema, peter j. mcdonnell, m.d, patrick j. o'sullivan, brenton l. saunders, ronald r. taylor, fred g. weiss m for yes for
2. to approve, in a non-binding vote, named executive officer compensation m for yes for
3. to ratify, in a non-binding vote, the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp as the company's independent auditor for the fiscal year ending december 31, 2016 and to authorize, in a binding vote, the board of directors, acting through the audit and compliance committee, to determine pricewaterhousecoopers llp's remuneration m for yes for
4a. to approve the amendment of the company's: memorandum of association to make certain administrative amendments m for yes for
4b. to approve the amendment of the company's: articles of association to make certain administrative amendments m for yes for
5a. to approve the amendment of the company's articles of association in order to: provide for a plurality voting standard in the event of a contested election m for yes for
5b. to approve the amendment of the company's articles of association in order to: grant the board of directors sole authority to determine its size m for yes for
6. to approve the reduction of company capital m for yes for
7. to consider a shareholder proposal regarding an annual report on lobbying activities, if properly presented at the meeting s against yes against
8. to consider a shareholder proposal regarding an independent board chairman, if properly presented at the meeting s against yes against

  aon plc
Ticker: AON CUSIP: G0408V102
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 6/24/2016        

1. re-election of director: lester b. knight, gregory c. case, fulvio conti, cheryl a. francis, james w. leng, j. michael losh, robert s. morrison, richard b. myers, richard c. notebaert, gloria santona, carolyn y. woo m for yes for
2. advisory vote to approve executive compensation. m for yes for
3. advisory vote to approve the directors' remuneration report. m for yes for
4. receipt of aon's annual report and accounts, together with the reports of the directors and auditors, for the year ended december 31, 2015. m for yes for
5. ratification of the appointment of ernst & young llp as aon's independent registered public accounting firm. m for yes for
6. re-appointment of ernst & young llp as aon's u.k. statutory auditor under the companies act 2006. m for yes for
7. authorization of the board of directors to determine the remuneration of aon's u.k. statutory auditor. m for yes for
8. approval of forms of share repurchase contracts and repurchase counterparties. m for yes for
9. authorize the board of directors to exercise all powers of aon to allot shares. m for yes for
10. authorize the board of directors to allot equity securities for cash without rights of preemption. m for yes for
11. authorize aon and its subsidiaries to make political donations or expenditures. m for yes for

  berkshire hathaway, inc. (b)
Ticker: BRK/B CUSIP: 084670702
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 4/30/2016        

1. director: warren e. buffett, charles t. munger, howard g. buffett, stephen b. burke, susan l. decker, william h. gates iii, david s. gottesman, charlotte guyman, thomas s. murphy, ronald l. olson, walter scott, jr., meryl b. witmer m for yes for
2. shareholder proposal regarding the reporting of risks posed by climate change. s against yes against

  catamaran corporation
Ticker: CTRX CUSIP: 148887102
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  special Meeting : 7/14/2015        

1. to consider and vote upon a proposal to approve the special resolution set forth in the proxy circular and proxy statement (the "arrangement resolution") approving an arrangement under section 195 of the business corporations act (yukon) (the "arrangement") contemplated by the arrangement agreement dated as of 3/29/15 by and among catamaran corporation ("catamaran") unitedhealth group incorporated-a corporation incorporated under the laws of the state of minnesota ...(due to space limits see proxy statement for full proposal). m for yes for
2. to consider and vote on a proposal to approve, on a non-binding, advisory basis, certain compensation that may be paid or become payable to catamaran's named executive officers that is based on or otherwise relates to the arrangement. m for yes for
3. to consider and vote on a proposal to adjourn the special meeting to another place, date or time if necessary or appropriate, to the extent permitted by the arrangement agreement, including to solicit additional proxies in favor of the proposal to approve the arrangement resolution if there are insufficient votes at the time of the special meeting to approve the arrangement resolution. m for yes for

  diageo plc
Ticker: DEO CUSIP: 25243Q205
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 9/23/2015        

1. report and accounts 2015. m for yes for
2. directors' remuneration report 2015. m for yes for
3. declaration of final dividend. m for yes for
4. re-election of pb bruzelius as a director. (audit, nomination & remuneration committee) m for yes for
5. re-election of lord davies as a director. (audit, nomination, remuneration committee(chairman of the committee)) m for yes for
6. re-election of ho kwonping as a director. (audit, nomination & remuneration committee) m for yes for
7. re-election of bd holden as a director. (audit, nomination & remuneration committee) m for yes for
8. re-election of dr fb humer as a director. (nomination committee(chairman of the committee)) m for yes for
9. re-election of d mahlan as a director. (executive committee) m for yes for
10. re-election of ns mendelsohn as a director. (audit, nomination & remuneration committee) m for yes for
11. re-election of i menezes as a director. (executive committee(chairman of the committee)) m for yes for
12. re-election of pg scott as a director. (audit(chairman of the committee), nomination, remuneration committee) m for yes for
13. re-election of ajh stewart as a director. (audit, nomination, remuneration committee) m for yes for
14. appointment of auditor. m for yes for
15. remuneration of auditor. m for yes for
16. authority to allot shares. m for yes for
17. disapplication of pre-emption rights. m for yes for
18. authority to purchase own ordinary shares. m for yes for
19. authority to make political donations and/or to incur political expenditure in the eu. m for yes for

  discovery communications, inc.
Ticker: DISCA CUSIP: 25470F104
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/19/2016        

1. director: paul a. gould, m. lavoy robison m for yes for
2. ratification of the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp as discovery communications, inc.'s independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending december 31, 2016. m for yes for
3. a stockholder proposal requesting the board of directors to report on plans to increase diverse representation on the board. s against yes against
4. a stockholder proposal requesting the compensation committee to report on the feasibility of integrating sustainability metrics into senior executive performance measures. s against yes against

  endo international plc
Ticker: ENDP CUSIP: G30401106
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 6/9/2016        

1. election of director: roger h. kimmel, rajiv de silva, shane m. cooke, arthur j. higgins, nancy j. hutson, ph.d., michael hyatt, william p. montague, jill d. smith, william f. spengler, douglas s. ingram, todd sisitsky m for yes for
2. to approve the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp as the company's independent auditors for the year ending december 31, 2016 and to authorize the audit committee of the board of directors to determine the auditors' remuneration. m for yes for
3. to approve, by advisory vote, named executive officer compensation. m for yes for
4. to approve the amendment of the company's memorandum of association. m for yes for
5. to approve the amendment of the company's articles of association. m for yes for
6. to approve the amendment of the company's 2015 stock incentive plan. m for yes for

  eog resources, inc.
Ticker: EOG CUSIP: 26875P101
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 4/26/2016        

1. election of director: janet f. clark, charles r. crisp, james c. day, h. leighton steward, donald f. textor, william r. thomas, frank g. wisner m for yes for
2. to ratify the appointment by the audit committee of the board of directors of deloitte & touche llp, independent registered public accounting firm, as auditors for the company for the year ending december 31, 2016. m for yes for
3. to approve, by non-binding vote, the compensation of the company's named executive officers. m for yes for

  express scripts holding company
Ticker: ESRX CUSIP: 30219G108
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/4/2016        

1. election of director: maura c. breen, william j. delaney, elder granger, md, mg, usa (retired), nicholas j. lahowchic, thomas p. mac mahon, frank mergenthaler, woodrow a. myers, jr., md, roderick a. palmore, george paz, william l. roper, md, mph, seymour sternberg, timothy wentworth m for yes for
2. to ratify the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp as the company's independent registered public accountants for 2016. m for yes for
3. to approve, by non-binding vote, executive compensation. m for yes for
4. to approve and ratify the express scripts holding company 2016 long-term incentive plan. m for yes for
5. stockholder proposal regarding an independent board chairman. s against yes for
6. stockholder proposal regarding political activities disclosure. s against yes against

  halliburton company
Ticker: HAL CUSIP: 406216101
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/18/2016        

1. election of director: a.f. al khayyal, a.m. bennett, j.r. boyd, m. carroll, n.k. dicciani, m.s. gerber, j.c. grubisich, d.j. lesar, r.a. malone, j.l. martin, j.a. miller, d.l. reed m for yes for
2. proposal for ratification of the selection of auditors. m for yes for
3. advisory approval of the company's executive compensation. m for yes for

  laboratory corporation of america holdings
Ticker: LH CUSIP: 50540R409
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/11/2016        

1. election of director: kerrii b. anderson, jean-luc belingard, d. gary gilliland, m.d., ph.d., david p. king, garheng kong, m.d., ph.d., robert e. mittelstaedt, jr., peter m. neupert, richelle p. parham, adam h. schechter, r. sanders williams, m.d. m for yes for
2. to approve, by non-binding vote, executive compensation. m for yes for
3. to approve the company's 2016 omnibus incentive plan. m for yes for
4. to approve the company's 2016 employee stock purchase plan. m for yes for
5. ratification of the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp ...(due to space limits, see proxy statement for full proposal). m for yes for
6. shareholder proposal to require board reports related to the zika virus. s against yes against

  liberty media corporation - cl c
Ticker: LMCK CUSIP: 531229300
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  special Meeting : 4/11/2016        

1. a proposal to approve the adoption of an amendment and restatement of our certificate of incorporation, among other things, to reclassify and exchange our existing common stock by exchanging the shares of our existing common stock for newly issued shares of three new tracking stocks, to be designated the liberty siriusxm common stock, the liberty braves common stock and the liberty media common stock, and to provide for the attribution of the businesses, assets and ...(due to space limits, see proxy material for full proposal) m for yes for
2. a proposal to approve the adoption of an amendment and restatement of our certificate of incorporation, in connection with the reclassification and exchange of our existing common stock, among other things, to reclassify and exchange each outstanding share of our existing series a, series b and series c common stock by exchanging each such share for the following upon the cancellation thereof: one newly issued share of the corresponding series of liberty siriusxm common ...(due to space limits, see proxy material for full proposal) m for yes for
3. a proposal to approve the adoption of an amendment and restatement of our certificate of incorporation, in connection with the reclassification and exchange of our existing common stock, among other things, to provide the board of directors with discretion to convert shares of common stock intended to track the performance of any of the siriusxm group, the braves group or the media group into common stock intended to track the performance of one of such other groups. m for yes for
4. a proposal to approve the adoption of an amendment and restatement of our certificate of incorporation, in connection with the reclassification and exchange of our existing common stock, among other things, to provide the board of directors with discretion to permit the sale of all or substantially all of the assets of a group without a vote of the holders of the stock of that group, if the net proceeds of such sale are distributed to holders of that stock by means of a dividend or ...(due to space limits, see proxy material for full proposal) m for yes for
5. a proposal to authorize the adjournment of the special meeting by liberty media to permit further solicitation of proxies, if necessary or appropriate, if sufficient votes are not represented at the special meeting to approve the other proposals to be presented at the special meeting. m for yes for

  mastercard incorporated
Ticker: MA CUSIP: 57636Q104
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 6/28/2016        

1. director: richard haythornthwaite, ajay banga, silvio barzi, david r. carlucci, steven j. freiberg, julius genachowski, merit e. janow, nancy j. karch, oki matsumoto, rima qureshi, jose octavio reyes lagunes, jackson tai m for yes for
2. advisory approval of mastercard's executive compensation m for yes for
3. ratification of the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp as the independent registered public accounting firm for mastercard for 2016 m for yes for

  monsanto company
Ticker: MON CUSIP: 61166W101
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 1/29/2016        

1. election of director: gregory h. boyce, david l. chicoine, ph.d., janice l. fields, hugh grant, arthur h. harper, laura k. ipsen, marcos m. lutz, c. steve mcmillan, jon r. moeller, william u. parfet, george h. poste, ph.d., d.v.m., robert j. stevens, patricia verduin, ph.d m for yes for
2. ratify the appointment of deloitte & touche llp as our independent registered public accounting firm for fiscal 2016. m for yes for
3. advisory (non-binding) vote to approve executive compensation. m for yes for
4. approval of code section 162(m) annual incentive plan. m for yes for
5. shareowner proposal: glyphosate report. s against yes against
6. shareowner proposal: lobbying report. s against yes against
7. shareowner proposal: independent board chairman. s against yes against

  motorola solutions inc.
Ticker: MSI CUSIP: 620076307
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/16/2016        

1. election of director: gregory q. brown, kenneth c. dahlberg, egon p. durban, michael v. hayden, clayton m. jones, judy c. lewent, gregory k. mondre, anne r. pramaggiore, samuel c. scott, iii m for yes for
2. advisory approval of the company's executive compensation. m for yes for
3. ratification of the appointment of kpmg llp as the company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2016. m for yes for
4. stockholder proposal re: lobbying disclosure. s against yes against

  omnicom group inc.
Ticker: OMC CUSIP: 681919106
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/24/2016        

1. election of director: john d. wren, bruce crawford, alan r. batkin, mary c. choksi, robert charles clark, leonard s. coleman, jr., susan s. denison, michael a. henning, deborah j. kissire, john r. murphy, john r. purcell, linda johnson rice m for yes for
2. ratification of the appointment of kpmg llp as the company's independent auditors for the 2016 fiscal year. m for yes for
3. advisory vote to approve the company's executive compensation. m for yes for
4. shareholder proposal requiring annual disclosure of eeo-1 data. s against yes against
5. shareholder proposal requiring an independent board chairman. s against yes against

  oracle corporation
Ticker: ORCL CUSIP: 68389X105
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 11/18/2015        

1. director: jeffrey s. berg, h. raymond bingham, michael j. boskin, safra a. catz, bruce r. chizen, george h. conrades, lawrence j. ellison, hector garcia-molina, jeffrey o. henley, mark v. hurd, leon e. panetta, naomi o. seligman m for yes for
2. re-approval of the oracle corporation executive bonus plan. m for yes for
3. advisory vote to approve executive compensation m for yes for
4. ratification of the selection of ernst & young llp as independent registered public accounting firm for fiscal year 2016. m for yes for
5. stockholder proposal regarding renewable energy targets. s against yes against
6. stockholder proposal regarding proxy access. s against yes against
7. stockholder proposal regarding quantifiable performance metrics. s against yes against
8. stockholder proposal regarding amendment of the governance guidelines s against yes against
9. stockholder proposal regarding vote tabulation. s against yes against
10. stockholder proposal regarding lobbying report. s against yes against

  pioneer natural resources company
Ticker: PXD CUSIP: 723787107
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/19/2016        

1. election of director: edison c. buchanan, andrew f. cates, timothy l. dove, phillip a. gobe, larry r. grillot, stacy p. methvin, royce w. mitchell, frank a. risch, scott d. sheffield, mona k. sutphen, j. kenneth thompson, phoebe a. wood, michael d. wortley m for yes for
2. ratification of selection of ernst & young llp as the company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2016 m for yes for
3. advisory vote to approve named executive officer compensation m for yes for
4. approval of the amended and restated 2006 long-term incentive plan m for yes for
5. approval of the material terms of the amended and restated 2006 long-term incentive plan to comply with the stockholder approval requirements of section 162(m) of the internal revenue code m for yes for

  praxair, inc.
Ticker: PX CUSIP: 74005P104
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 4/26/2016        

1. election of director: stephen f. angel, oscar bernardes, nance k. dicciani, edward g. galante, ira d. hall, raymond w. leboeuf, larry d. mcvay, denise l. ramos, martin h. richenhagen, wayne t. smith, robert l. wood m for yes for
2. to ratify the appointment of the independent auditor m for yes for
3. to approve, on an advisory and non-binding basis, the compensation of praxair's named executive officers m for yes for
4. to approve the material terms of performance goals under praxair's section 162(m) plan m for yes for
5. shareholder proposal regarding dividends and share repurchases s against yes against

  precision castparts corp.
Ticker: PCP CUSIP: 740189105
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 8/17/2015        

1. election of director: peter b. delaney, mark donegan, don r. graber, lester l. lyles, vernon e. oechsle, james f. palmer, ulrich schmidt, richard l. wambold, timothy a. wicks, janet c. wolfenbarger m for yes for
2. ratification of appointment of independent registered public accounting firm m for yes for
3. advisory vote regarding compensation of named executive officers m for yes for
4. shareholder proposal regarding proxy access s against yes against

  precision castparts corp.
Ticker: PCP CUSIP: 740189105
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  special Meeting : 11/19/2015        

1. approve the agreement and plan of merger, dated as of august 8, 2015, by and among berkshire hathaway inc., nw merger sub inc., and precision castparts corp. m for yes for
2. approve on a non-binding, advisory basis the compensation that may be paid or become payable to the company's named executive officers in connection with, or following, the consummation of the merger. m for yes for

  range resources corporation
Ticker: RRC CUSIP: 75281A109
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/18/2016        

1. election of director: brenda a. cline, anthony v. dub, allen finkelson, james m. funk, christopher a. helms, mary ralph lowe, gregory g. maxwell, kevin s. mccarthy, jeffrey l. ventura m for yes for
2. a proposal to approve the compensation philosophy, policies and procedures described in the compensation discussion and analysis. m for yes for
3. a proposal to ratify the terms of the company's 2005 equity plan to utilize performance based compensation. m for yes for
4. to ratify the appointment of ernst & young llp as our independent registered public accounting firm as of and for the fiscal year ending december 31, 2016. m for yes for
5. stockholder proposal - requesting publication of a political spending report. s against yes against

  transdigm group incorporated
Ticker: TDG CUSIP: 893641100
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 3/2/2016        

1. director: william dries, mervin dunn, michael graff, w. nicholas howley, raymond laubenthal, robert small m for yes for
2. to approve (in an advisory vote) compensation paid to the company's named executive officers m for yes for
3. to ratify the selection of ernst & young llp as the company's independent accountants for the fiscal year ending september 30, 2016 m for yes for

  twenty-first century fox, inc. - cl b
Ticker: FOX CUSIP: 90130A200
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 11/12/2015        

1. election of director: k. rupert murdoch, lachlan k. murdoch, delphine arnault, james w. breyer, chase carey, david f. devoe, viet dinh, sir roderick i. eddington, james r. murdoch, jacques nasser, robert s. silberman, tidjane thiam, jeffrey w. ubben m for yes for
2. proposal to ratify the selection of ernst & young llp as the company's independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending june 30, 2016. m for yes for
3. advisory vote on executive compensation m for yes for
4. citizenship certification-please mark "yes" if the stock is owned of record or beneficially by a u.s. stockholder or mark "no" if such stock is owned of record or beneficially by a non-u.s. stockholder. (please refer to appendix b of the proxy statement for additional guidance.) if you do not provide a response to this item 4 you will be deemed to be a non-u.s. stockholder and the shares will be subject to the suspension of voting rights. m for yes for

  united parcel service, inc.
Ticker: UPS CUSIP: 911312106
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 5/5/2016        

1. election of director to serve until the 2017 annual meeting: david p. abney, rodney c. adkins, michael j. burns, william r. johnson, candace kendle, ann m. livermore, rudy h.p. markham, clark t. randt, jr., john t. stankey, carol b. tome, kevin m. warsh m for yes for
2. to ratify the appointment of deloitte & touche llp as ups's independent registered public accounting firm for the year ending december 31, 2016. m for yes for
3. shareowner proposal to prepare an annual report on lobbying activities. s against yes against
4. shareowner proposal to reduce the voting power of class a stock from 10 votes per share to one vote per share. s against yes against
5. shareowner proposal to adopt holy land principles. s against yes against

  wells fargo & company
Ticker: WFC CUSIP: 949746101
Proposal
Presenter*
Management
Recommendation
Voted Weitz
Vote
  annual Meeting : 4/26/2016        

1. election of director: john d. baker ii, elaine l. chao, john s. chen, lloyd h. dean, elizabeth a. duke, susan e. engel, enrique hernandez, jr., donald m. james, cynthia h. milligan, federico f. pena, james h. quigley, stephen w. sanger, john g. stumpf, susan g. swenson, suzanne m. vautrinot m for yes for
2. vote on an advisory resolution to approve executive compensation. m for yes for
3. ratify the appointment of kpmg llp as the company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2016. m for yes for
4. adopt a policy to require an independent chairman. s against yes against
5. provide a report on the company's lobbying policies and practices. s against yes against

* M = Management, S = Shareholders